Skip to content
Zevqi
AI Engineering

How to Review AI-Generated Code: A 10-Point Checklist

A practical checklist for reviewing code written by AI agents: scope, assumptions, error paths, tests, sensitive areas, and the final test of whether you can explain it.

By Neha SinghPublished November 16, 20266 min read

Reviewing AI-generated code is not the same as reviewing a colleague’s pull request. The author has no intent to ask about, the diff is often larger than a human would write, and the code looks polished even when it is wrong. This ten-point checklist helps you review it properly without spending an afternoon on every change.

Before you read a line

  1. Check the scope. List the files changed. Did the agent touch anything you did not expect? Unexpected files are the first red flag.
  2. Read the task, then predict the shape. Before opening the diff, decide what a sensible change would look like. Compare it with what you got.
  3. Prefer small diffs. If the change is huge, ask the agent to split it. Nobody reviews 800 lines well.

While you read

  1. Hunt for assumptions. Where does the code assume a value is present, sorted, unique or trusted? Those assumptions are where bugs live.
  2. Check error paths. Agents write the happy path well. Look at timeouts, empty inputs, partial failures and retries.
  3. Question new dependencies. Is each package needed, maintained and appropriately licensed? Did it add one when a standard library call would do?
  4. Read the tests critically. A test written by the same agent can pass for the wrong reason. Ask what bug each test would catch.
  5. Treat sensitive code differently. Authentication, billing, permissions, migrations and infrastructure deserve a slower, second-person review.

Before you merge

  1. Run it. Execute the change, try an edge case, break it on purpose.
  2. Confirm you could explain it. The final test: can you tell a teammate what changed, why, and where it might fail, without looking? If not, you have not finished reviewing.

Why step ten is the one teams skip

Approval and understanding are different things. A pull request can collect approvals from people who skimmed it, and the codebase quietly accumulates code nobody can explain. That is comprehension debt.

One way to enforce step ten is a short check right after the change: a few questions about behaviour, edge cases and risk, answered by the developer who accepted it. Zevqi automates this for Claude Code: it explains each AI-written change and quizzes you on it, and shows your team which files have a person who has actually passed. See how it looks in the demo dashboard.

A quick review template

  • What was the goal?
  • Which files changed, and is that list expected?
  • What are the three riskiest lines?
  • What happens on failure or bad input?
  • What did the tests actually prove?
  • Could I explain this to a new teammate?

Frequently asked questions

Should AI review AI-written code?

It can catch real issues and is a useful first pass, but it shares blind spots with the writer. Keep a human accountable for understanding.

How long should a review take?

Long enough to answer the template above. For small, low-risk diffs that is a few minutes; for sensitive code, much longer.

Try a free 7-day trial to see which of your AI-changed files nobody has actually understood.

Written by Neha Singh

Neha Singh is the founder of Zevqi. She builds and tests the tools on this site and writes these guides from hands-on use. Follow on X (@heynehasingh) or read more about Zevqi.

Try it now

Ready to put this into practice? Zevqi has the tools built in — free, no signup.